Skip to the content

Rettler Insurance Group - Insuring West Bend and All of Wisconsin

Rettler Insurance Group is your local independent insurance agent serving clients in Wisconsin. We proudly serve the West Bend, Wisconsin community and provide affordable and reliable insurance choices that are tailored to fit your unique needs for auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, and business insurance.

At Rettler Insurance Group, we pride ourselves in being honest and reliable insurance advisors. With over 10 years of experience, we are well-versed in the insurance industry and will guide you on what insurance coverages you need to protect what you value most. Our main focus is to educate you about the coverage options available to you and help you pick the best coverages that fits all of your needs.

Agency Principal, Susan Rettler, began her insurance career in 2007. During her nine years of handling claims, she worked with really good insureds who had received bad advice from agents who only saw dollars, and not sense. As a result, she decided to take her expertise and use it to educate and consult those who need insurance. Because of her claims experience, Susan’s main goal is to educate people about their insurance coverage to prevent future insurance problems.

Susan chose to become an agent so that she could guide people into choosing coverages that are right for them. After her claims experience, she spent some time working as a Farmers agent and then as an agent working for an independent agency. Both work experiences have taught her so much and have prepared her to be an honest and reliable insurance advisor. The combination of claims and agent experiences are what makes her and The Rettler Insurance Group, the right agent for you. Let Rettler Insurance Group, be your expert insurance resource for all your insurance needs!

Specializing In Erie Insurance

Erie Insurance has been helping customers since 1925 with their auto, home, business, and life insurance needs.
Susan Rettler headshot
Susan Rettler
Agency Owner
See All Reviews

Recent News & Updates

Cybersecurity Awareness Month: Does Your Business Need Cyber Liability Insurance?

Every October, the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) leads Cybersecurity Awareness Month, a nationwide effort to help individuals and organizations better protect themselves online. For small and mid-sized businesses, it's also a timely reminder to think about how a cyberattack or data breach could affect operations, and whether cyber liability insurance has a role to play in your risk management plan. Why Cyber Risk...

Fire Prevention Week: Home Safety Steps and What Your Homeowners Insurance Covers

Every October, the National Fire Protection Association observes Fire Prevention Week, which falls on October 4-10 in 2026. The observance began over a century ago to mark the anniversary of the Great Chicago Fire, and it remains a helpful reminder to check the basics of home fire safety before colder weather sends more people back to their stoves, fireplaces, and space heaters. Common Causes of...

National Disability Employment Awareness Month: Building an Inclusive Workplace

Every October, the U.S. Department of Labor observes National Disability Employment Awareness Month (NDEAM), a nationwide observance that recognizes the contributions of workers with disabilities and highlights the importance of inclusive hiring and employment practices. The Department of Labor's theme for 2026 is "Celebrating Value and Talent," which underscores the skills and perspectives that employees with disabilities bring to their workplaces. What NDEAM Recognizes NDEAM...

Smart Homes: What Connected Devices Mean for Your Insurance

From thermostats that learn your habits to sensors that detect water leaks, connected technology is changing the way we live—and the way insurance companies think about risk. For homeowners, these devices do more than make life easier. They can help prevent costly damage, alert you before problems escalate, and even lower your insurance premiums. Many insurers are now rewarding homeowners who adopt smart technology with...

ERIE's YourTurn® Program

There is a new way Erie Insurance is looking out for you and wants to help you stay safe on the road.

Learn More